Monday, March 19, 2018

New Hampshire Parents Object to Book That Calls Jesus a “Vagrant”

December 20, 2010 by  
Filed under Monthly Articles, World News


A New Hampshire couple told a school board Monday that their son’s civil rights were violated when he was assigned a book that refers Jesus Christ as a “wine-guzzling vagrant and precocious socialist.”

The 2001 book, “Nickel and Dimed: On (Not) Getting By in America,” documents author Barbara Ehrenreich’s attempts to live on minimum wage as she critiques the nation’s economic system.

Aimee and Dennis Taylor complained about the book’s foul language, descriptions of drug use and characterization of Christianity when it was assigned to their son’s personal finance class at Bedford High School in the fall and later pulled him out of school at his request. On Monday, they asked the school board to remove the book from the curriculum and create a committee of parents to review and rate all other books used in the school, but the board held off on making a decision until it hears from its curriculum committee next month.

Dennis Taylor said school officials were either utterly careless in choosing the book or were “intentionally agreeing with Ehrenreich and taking the position that Jesus was a drunken bum.”

“The administration and the people with the master’s degrees taking care of our children clearly in this case seemed to lack common sense, common decency and with regard to civil rights, an understanding of common law,” he said.

He noted that had the book been turned into a movie, his son would be too young to see it given the obscenities. And both he and his wife said the passages about Jesus were an attack on their son’s faith.

In a passage describing a tent revival meeting she attended, Ehrenreich writes about feeling troubled by its emphasis on Jesus’ crucifixion and wishing the preacher would focus more on his teachings of social and economic justice.

“Jesus makes his appearance here only as a corpse; the living man, the wine-guzzling vagrant and precocious socialist, is never once mentioned, nor anything he ever had to say,” she wrote.

In a “Q&A” section on her blog, Ehrenreich denies that the passage insults Jesus and points out that the book has won a Christopher Award, given by a Catholic group to recognize books that “affirm the highest values of the human spirit.”

“In the section at issue, I observed that the social teachings of Jesus went utterly unmentioned at the tent revival I attended. The revival preachers clearly preferred the dead and risen Christ to the living Jesus – who did indeed drink wine and could even make it out of water,” she wrote. “As for the vagrancy charge: that’s what he was, a homeless, itinerant preacher.”

In response to the Taylors’ initial complaint, the district had a committee that included administrators, a teacher and two parents evaluate the book. The panel decided in October that the book’s educational merit outweighed its shortcomings, but it instructed teachers to offer an alternative to students whose parents objected.

In November, Superintendent Tim Mayes asked teachers to review the course’s curriculum and come up with a better balance of materials to support its objectives.

“I thought we could seek better balance in terms of covering multiple topics in personal finance, and maybe we were spending too much time on the one topic of working as a minimum wage employee,” he said Monday.

The school district’s curriculum committee is expected to make a decision based on the teachers’ recommendations next month, before the next semester starts in late January. Several board members said they would let that process play out before weighing in on the book’s merits.

The board’s vice-chairwoman, Cindy Chagnon, said she agreed the book might not be appropriate for a personal finance course but said she viewed the comments about Jesus as positive.

“Her underlying point is not prejudiced against religion. She’s saying Christ is a living, breathing lesson for us, let’s listen to what he says,” she said. “I think this doesn’t necessarily belong in personal finance … but I would not hold anyone on our staff accountable for choosing a bad book. It teaches lessons of the human spirit.”

Click Here

Comments are closed.